I think you are agreeing with me.Darkson wrote:Er - that's what the rules say.Gimli wrote:I still think the coach with DT should get to keep his player standing and a second chance to decide to use DT after he sees the RR, just like the coach with Dodge gets to keep his player standing (in his original square) and a second chance to decide to use Dodge after the RR.
But I think Galak and Ian Williams disagree - see their posts above. I'm saying if a player declares a DT use and the dodger declares a TRR, then the DT player is NOT placed prone. Rather he stays standing, the dodger rerolls, and the DT player gets to look at the rerolled dodge roll before deciding to use DT on the reroll. The difference is that he could stay standing after the second roll if the dodger fails the dodge without the DT, or the dodger succeeds even with DT. Is that how you play the rule?