Manuel wrote:Well, yes indeed. White Dwarf's chaos daemons, squigs and so on were as house rules as any other crazy stuff.
Chaos Daemons, Squigs, the Kantona Kick, Snotling Pump Wagons, Forest Folk, etc were Citadel Journal, not White Dwarf. So yes, they were house rules. (officially, while the CJ was around, all rules in WD were considered official unless stated otherwise, all in CJ were unofficial unless stated otherwise).
(Daemons
were revised and made official in the
popular and long-lasting
4th edition. Which also wasn't in White Dwarf.)
As far as I can recall, the only WD published
rules for BB 3rd/4th/LRB were the Norse, possibly lizards and/or 'zons (I don't think so, but I'm not certain), an update to Dungeonbowl (which I'm pretty sure was clearly noted as being unofficial), and nerfing 2+ regeneration to 4+. WD mostly ran match reports, tactics articles, FAQ and "Look at the shiny new models! Buy the shiny new models!"
Instead of that nice clean "these rules are official, these ones are house rules we thought were worth sharing", what we've got here is a weird ambiguous "give-it-a-shot" whatsit, in which (to paraphrase the second post) 'here are some crazy new rules, just for fun, but they're still rules, but they're not official, except that they might be, I don't know, what do you think?'. I'm all for flexibility in rules, and encouraging players to tailor the rules to suit their league (or format of choice), but a good customisable ruleset requires a clear starting position.
CyberedElf wrote:Optional rules =/= house rules (no matter how stupid the optional rules are)
To exclude OR include optional rules is a house rule.
No it isn't: LRB6 p16 / BB2016 "The Official Rules" p22. "All of the following extra rules are optional. This means..."
Regardless of whether you include all the optional rules, none of them or somewhere in between, you are following this rule.
For LRB6, as long as you are only including rules from LRB6, you are following this rule. If you start to include rules from
outisde LRB6, you are bringing in house rules. If you exclude rules from earlier in the book (eg 4-minute turn timers), you're also bringing in house rules. But if you're only picking and choosing from the optional section, then you are following the official rules.
BB2016 is more complicated, due to splitting the rules up across multiple books. p22 goes on to mention future supplements. Clearly one of these is Death Zone Season One, and equally clearly, any subsequent DZ "Seasons". Beyond that it's anyone's guess. Are promo cards supplements? Is a White Dwarf article? Is a pdf downloaded from the bloodbowl.com website? Is an email from a game designer? Is an app? I'm not sure there's an official answer for any of those. Yay clarity!
Personally, I'll be considering everything that isn't in the base game or a Death Zone supplement (or errata) to be house rules unless clearly and specifically declared otherwise.