Page 2 of 2

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 1:22 pm
by Glowworm
So,

Day 1 entry with a winner
Day 2 entry with a winner

Day 1&2 entry with a winner

Would anyone who played both days be eligable for the day 1 win, so win 2 NAF tournaments in the same weekend......

Must say I'm suprised that even tho I offered to keep the 1 day format intact it's still an overwhelming call for no change.......

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 1:54 pm
by besters
glowworm wrote: Must say I'm suprised that even tho I offered to keep the 1 day format intact it's still an overwhelming call for no change.......
Why? Great tournament as it is!

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 2:00 pm
by Glowworm
besters wrote:
glowworm wrote: Must say I'm suprised that even tho I offered to keep the 1 day format intact it's still an overwhelming call for no change.......
Why? Great tournament as it is!
Because I'm still offering that and more for those who may want more..........

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 3:23 pm
by frogboy
glowworm wrote:
Must say I'm suprised that even tho I offered to keep the 1 day format intact it's still an overwhelming call for no change.......
It's only 10 votes to 3, how many coaches were at the event this year when you talked about this, lots of people seemed interested then.

I got to say I like 1 day events, but having the option of both is fantastic.

You could have your best newcomer awards etc on day one then the more serious stuff on the second, have two different rule sets then restart on the second day but you could add both results together for overall Crumb-Bowl Champion.

That's what I'd do if I could run a tournament ;)

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 3:30 pm
by Glowworm
The other option is I run a 2 Dayer totally seperate........ HMMMM, maybe that's the way to go.....

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 3:37 pm
by frogboy
More tournaments is good :D

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 3:55 pm
by Be4ch
glowworm wrote:The other option is I run a 2 Dayer totally seperate........ HMMMM, maybe that's the way to go.....
Why not try something like Orclahoma Bowl/Spiky Cup where they have 2 1 day tournaments on consecutive days - 1 on Saturday, 1 on Sunday - and people can enter either or both. Each is an individually sanctioned NAF tournament and each has their own winners but there's an overall winner for the coach that played in both days. Each day has different rules and structures so could be fun

http://www.orclahomabowl.com/index.htm

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 4:42 pm
by Loki
Hi mate, I voted no change, basically on the thinking 'if it ain't broke...'

If you want to run 2x 1 dayer or even a straight 2 dayer then go for it. If you build it they will come ;)

I'm pretty sure Burger Bowl in Scotland last year ran as two 1 dayers Sat & Sun if you want feedback from a UK TO.

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sat Nov 21, 2015 7:47 pm
by Maverick
Ok I usually can't make it as it clashes with last weeks of the hockey season, however able to come this year and happy either way, sat/sun would give me a headache about bloodbowl over hockey though ;-)

Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Sun Nov 22, 2015 1:11 pm
by nazgob
I tend to let the hockey go, personally.

Helps that I'm not very good though.

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Mon Nov 23, 2015 8:55 am
by nonumber
Reason why I voted for no change -

I love a one-dayer. I think they are a credible and welcome addition to the tournament scene. They are useful for squeezing in that little extra bit of tournament Blood Bowl into the calendar without upsetting the boss too much.

That said, if you did some half n' half hybrid as you described it... should the stars align and pigs fly and I won the tournament on the Saturday I would not feel as though I have won anything. I was the highest ranked coach after game three... or maybe not even the highest ranked coach at all as your description goes... just the highest ranked coach out of those only doing day one. It's not really a thing.

Simply put, Crumb Bowl is the biggest one dayer on the calendar and I'd rather win a one dayer than half a two dayer. So, I voted for it to remain the same.

Re: Crumb-Bowl 5 1 or 2 Day

Posted: Mon Nov 23, 2015 1:44 pm
by Glowworm
nonumber wrote:
Simply put, Crumb Bowl is the biggest one dayer on the calendar and I'd rather win a one dayer than half a two dayer. So, I voted for it to remain the same.
THIS.....

It stays One day.

However, be aware that "Glowworm productions" may run a 2 dayer at another time, got some great ideas / twists that would not suit crumb.

Thank you all for your input, you have spoken, I have listened. :D