Page 1 of 7

Naming the common defensive setups

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 7:49 pm
by mattgslater
In a related thread ( http://www.talkbloodbowl.com/phpBB2/vie ... sc&start=0 ), I complain loudly about the lack of terminology for Blood Bowl, and propose some terms. However that turns out, clarity of game reports may benefit dramatically from a set of terms for offensive and defensive formations. Since offense keys off of defense, it seems natural to me that we start with defense.

This is the basic version of the most frequently used defense around here. My proposal in the above thread was to call this the "Ziggurat" after its appearance, and refer to the line formation as "101" because the Ends are one square off the middle and the Nose is on the zero-ground.

Code: Select all

The 101 Ziggurat
- - - -|- - x x x - -|- - - -
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - -
- - x -|- x - - - x -|- x - -
- x - -|x - - - - - x|- - x -
But there are lots of ways to do a defense, no? Let's name some others.

Dibs on the Slater Elf Defense, or the Inverted Ziggurat, which only works if the Corners have Side Step and the line has a number of positioning skills, but lets four players be protected.

Code: Select all

The Inverted Ziggurat
- - - -|- - x x x - -|- - - -
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - -
- x - -|x - - - - - x|- - x -
- - x -|- x - - - x -|- x-  -
And the (Half-Zig? Zig-Zag?) for bash teams with a single side stepper on one corner and one Stand Firm End.

Code: Select all

Compromise variant, with the all but two players cheated up to account for high ST and low MA.
- - - -|- - x x x - -|- - - -
- - x -|- x - - - - x|- - x -
- - - -|x - - - - x -|- - - -
- x - -|- - - - - - -|- x-  -
or something of the sort

I see this defense a lot, and I use it with some success against teams that don't handle the ball well. EDIT: Thechosengobbo suggests the name "Arrowhead" for this defense.

Code: Select all

202 Arrowhead
- - - -|- x - x - x -|- - - -
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - -
- - x -|x - - x - - x|- x - -
- x - -|- - - x - - -|- - x -
What about unusual characteristics? Here are some proposals. An "offset line" is one that isn't centered on 0, a "stacked line" has more than three players. An "asymmetric defense" is asymmetric in any way. A Deep Safety is more than two squares behind the Midfielders, and a deep defense is where no more than five defenders are within 3 squares of the LOS. What's a defense that leaves one WZ open? What about a defense where the Midfielders and Flankers are one square back instead of two?

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:02 pm
by Pug
Thought I'd do these as a tester for setup graphics.

The 101 Ziggurat
Image

Inverted Ziggurat
Image

Half Zig
Image

Unknown Defence
Image

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:05 pm
by mattgslater
Except the 101 Zig (which is the Half Zig with the corners back an extra square) you're bang on.

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:17 pm
by Pug
Just copied the "Code" layouts on the 1st post!?

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:19 pm
by Pug
Bugger!!

Just realised I copied the wrong image link...I'll edit it!

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:24 pm
by bjorn9486
I just wanted to chime in and say there are some interesting defense setups here. I'll have to try them in a game or two.

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 11:30 pm
by mattgslater
Another one I've seen, a variant on the Ziggurat for ST3 teams with Guard to use against bash (give Guard to the "safeties" cheated up to protect the midfielders from a blitz). Good on Humans or Dwarfs, who can't really protect the LOS from a bash line, but who can get S skills to play inside.

Code: Select all

- - - -|- - x x x - -|- - - - 
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - - 
- - x -|x x - - - x x|- x - - 
- x - -|- - - - - - -|- - x -
A variant that elf teams sometimes use against ST3.

Code: Select all

- - - -|- x-  x - x -|- - - - 
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - - 
- - x -|x - x - x - x|- x - - 
- x - -|- - - - - - -|- - x -
I guess these would both be called 3-6-2 alignments in American football. The way I see it, neither setup has any true safeties, the top one has four flankers (the two "outside midfielders" are flankers in practice, but it's sort of a Rorschach thing), the while second has a pair of centerfielders (a lot clearer, as all four interior defenders must be ready to take the blitz, making them all midfielders).

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 11:45 pm
by thechosengobbo
My local league colloquially calls your last 'unknown' set up for elf teams 'the arrowhead' whenever I use it. That name do anything for you?

Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 11:46 pm
by mattgslater
Awesome! Edited in.

Re: Naming the common defensive setups

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 7:46 am
by Ikterus
Pug. Concerning the Double Banana (love the name BTW) you missed a little on the 3D. Suicidal as it might be I position my flankers one square from the sidelines. The point of this setup is to paint the pitch with TZs making it harder for fast agility teams (that lack frenzy) to rush up for the 2 turn hand off-pass TD. Works well against the infamous Slann Two Turner too.

Love the 3D BTW. Keep it up! (is it sketch-up you're using?)

Code: Select all

Proper Double Banana
- - - -|x - - x - - x|- - - -
- x - -|- - - - - - -|- - x -
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - -
- - - -|x - - x - - x|- - - -
- x - -|- - - - - - -|- - x -
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - -
- - - -|- - - x - - -|- - - -

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 8:31 am
by Ikterus
And also, all of the above can be placed with the three LOS-players with spaces in between.

Code: Select all

- x - x - x -
instead of

Code: Select all

- - x x x - -
So maybe we need a name for those often used LOS placements?

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 8:44 am
by thechosengobbo
Ikterus wrote:And also, all of the above can be placed with the three LOS-players with spaces in between.

Code: Select all

- x - x - x -
instead of

Code: Select all

- - x x x - -
So maybe we need a name for those often used LOS placements?
"Linefodder" and "spaced linefodder" :lol:

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 11:04 am
by Pipey
I use the Ziggurat all the time. First saw Lucifer use it some years ago.

Great name for it though, gloriously whacky!

It does resemble a Ziggurat (stepped pyramid).

Re: Naming the common defensive setups

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 11:35 am
by bjorn9486
Ikterus wrote:

Code: Select all

Deep ?
- - - -|- - x x x - -|- - - -
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - -
- - x -|- x - - - x -|- x - -
- - - -|- - - - - - -|- - - -
- - - -|- - x - x - -|- - - -
- x - -|- - - - - - -|- - x -
The spider?

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 12:07 pm
by voyagers_uk
The Volcano?