Diving Catch & Completition

Don't understand a particular rule or just need to clarify something? This is the forum for you. With 2 of the BBRC members and the main LRB5/6 writer present at TFF, you're bound to get as good an answer as possible.

Moderator: TFF Mods

Toby

Diving Catch & Completition

Post by Toby »

LRB1.3 wrote: Diving Catch (Agility Skill)
The player may use this skill if the ball was thrown to him and missed. It allows the player to move one square after the ball has scattered. This move is made after the ball has scattered, but before it hits the ground or can be caught. No Dodge roll is required to make this move. If the move takes the player into the square that the ball is in then he is allowed to try and catch it. Although a player using a Diving Catch ends up on the ground
for a moment, because this is a controlled fall he will not be injured and he will almost instantly regain his feet. Therefore the player is not knocked over when he uses the skill.
Suggestion:
The player may use this skill if the ball was passed and missed.
*catch a ball that was originally thrown to a opposing player (interception, 2 SPP)
*catch a ball that was thrown to another teammate
*catch a ball that was thrown to an empty square
LRB1.3 wrote: Completions (COMP): A player who makes a accurate pass that is caught by another player earns 1 Star Player point. An accurate pass is called a ‘completion’ or complete pass. Note that the ball must be caught by a player from the same team, otherwise it is not complete!
Suggestion:
"A player who makes an pass that is caught by a teammate earns 1 star player point"
*Hail Marry Pass = Completition

Reason: ''
User avatar
DoubleSkulls
Da Admin
Posts: 8219
Joined: Wed May 08, 2002 12:55 pm
Location: Back in the UK
Contact:

Post by DoubleSkulls »

Isn't the problem with this that its the thrower, not the catcher who gets the SPPs. The thrower didn't do his part of the job (getting an accurate pass off) so doesn't benefit.

The catcher is probably getting 3 SPPs for the TD anyway, so doesn't need the extra 1.

Ian

Reason: ''
Toby

Post by Toby »

OK thats regarding the SPP for a missed pass that luckily completed;


DIVING CATCH can not even be USED if the Ball was passed/thrown to

*Another Player (Friend or Foe)
*Empty Square

I want to throw the ball to an empty square and catch it diving !!!

Reason: ''
User avatar
DoubleSkulls
Da Admin
Posts: 8219
Joined: Wed May 08, 2002 12:55 pm
Location: Back in the UK
Contact:

Post by DoubleSkulls »

Well house rule it then.

Ian

Reason: ''
Acerak
Rulz Guru
Posts: 801
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 1970 12:00 am
Location: Amherst, NY
Contact:

Post by Acerak »

Yeah, house rule it. Plain and simple. But we're not going to suddenly introduce SPPs for failed actions. And an inaccurate pass doesn't deserve a reward.

As for using DCatch on an empty square, you'll have to deal with multiple DCatchers in the same area. Currently, there's a limit of one player per turn using the skill. You'll have problems when you want to move two players at once. It's up to you, but it's strictly house rule material.

Cheers.

-Chet

Reason: ''
Marcus
Da Tulip Champ I
Posts: 1664
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 1970 12:00 am
Location: Australian in London
Contact:

Post by Marcus »

We tried houseruling this in an old league I used to run. The whole passing to an empty square to beat the defence idea seemed to fit in with the flavour of American Football and seemed to make an underused skill a little more useful.

The only problem is that it makes 1 turn TDs a damn sight more common as you can start your reciever on the line, then throw a pass in front of him, have him diving catch it, then have a whole extra square of movement.

We had a number of ideas to counter this but none were particularly satisfactory so we just 86ed the idea.

Marcus

Reason: ''
User avatar
Thadrin
Moaning Git
Posts: 8079
Joined: Mon Jul 30, 2001 12:00 am
Location: Norsca
Contact:

Post by Thadrin »

86ed it? theres a phrase I've not heard before.
Click my WWW link and you'll see why it interests me...

Reason: ''
I know a bear that you don't know. * ICEPELT IS MY HERO.
Master bleater. * Not in the clique.
Member of the "3 digit" club.
Toby

Post by Toby »

Acerak wrote:Yeah, house rule it. Plain and simple. But we're not going to suddenly introduce SPPs for failed actions. And an inaccurate pass doesn't deserve a reward.
ok ok our oppinon differs on that topic. i like more SPP and more money and more dead people so more new guys that get better faster - forget it.

I dont understand part 2;
What i want is:

If suddenly a ball lands one square away from a guy with diving catch, i want him to catch it. Handicap: no catch skill; Requirement: Flying ball, not boucing. so Accurate/Missed Pass (own or opposing team), Kick, Throw-In...
Plain: If you want to catch a ball 1 square away you need diving catch !

Marcus, can you tell me more ?

Reason: ''
User avatar
GalakStarscraper
Godfather of Blood Bowl
Posts: 15882
Joined: Tue Jun 26, 2001 12:00 am
Location: Indiana, USA
Contact:

Post by GalakStarscraper »

Thadrin wrote:86ed it? theres a phrase I've not heard before.
Click my WWW link and you'll see why it interests me...
From the Word-Detective:
The theory you've heard about "86" is certainly entertaining, but is unsubstantiated and probably not true. Fortunately, there are lots of other theories. Unfortunately, there's not much evidence supporting them, either. What we do know is that "86" first appeared as "kitchen slang" meaning "out of that item" in the 1930's, and fairly quickly came to mean "stop serving that customer" as well. Eventually, "86" spread to general usage, where it came to mean simply "dismiss" or "quash" ("The boss 86'ed my proposal for beer in the lunchroom").

The theory with the most logic behind it is that "86" began as rhyming slang code of the sort found in London's Cockney underworld of the 19th century. As "trouble and strife" meant "wife" in rhyming slang, "86" may have stood for "nix" -- "nix" meaning "nothing" or "to dismiss." How "86" then ended up in U.S. restaurants is a bit of a puzzle, but I'm afraid it's the best theory anyone has come up with so far.
and from Plateau Press:
eighty-six=nix
This verb meaning to eject or debar from premises, to reject or abandon was previously an expression used by waiters and bartenders indicating that the supply of an item was exhausted or that a customer was not to be served.
Morris Dictionary of Word and Phrase Origins says: [...] 86 may well have come from a number code created by [...] soda fountain clerks [...]. Originally, according to the American Thesaurus of Slang, it was a password used between clerks to indicate: 'We're all out of the item ordered.' The transition from this meaning [...] to the bartender's sense of 'Serve no more because of the shape he's in' is fairly obvious. The number code developed by soda clerks was very extensive [...]. A hissed '98' from one soda-popper to another indicated 'The assistant manager is prowling around. Watch out.' [...] And most cheerful warning of all, 87 1/2, meaning 'There's a good-looking girl out front!'
The earliest clear citation is from the February 1936 issue of American Speech, which gives the definition Eighty-six, item on the menu not on hand. The Random House Historical Dictionary of American Slang cites a comedy with a date range 1926-35 in which a waiter gives his number as 86.
AHD3 gives the etymology: Perhaps after Chumley's bar and restaurant at 86 Bedford Street in Greenwich Village, New York City.
But most other dictionaries, including MWCD10, suggest that eighty-six was rhyming slang for nix.
On its AOL message Board, Merriam-Webster Editorial Department writes: The etymology we give at 'eighty-six' is the one we'll stand by. It is our contention that the address at Chumley's is purely coincidence, and that the word was developed in rhyming slang, and originally used by restaurant workers so that the average customer didn't know what they were talking about. The earlier citations for 'eighty-six' [...] do not influence our decisions about the etymology [...]. In fact, if the first citation is from the early part of the range, it would tell against the Chumley's hypothesis, as Chumley's did not exist before 1927-29. Finally, because slang usually exists in the language for a number of years before it is recorded, the existence of a citation from the 1920s tells strongly against the Chumley's explanation.
There are a number of other theories about the origin of the word: that it originated in the heyday of the British merchant marine (the standard crew was 85, so that the 86th didn't get to go); that 86 was the number of the California (or Florida) law that forbade bartenders to serve the overly intoxicated; and that it refers to the number of tables (85) at the New York restaurant 21, and the table (86, in other words, no table) that the undesirable got.
There are more, but the Chumley's theory is the most popular.
Eighty-six is attested as a verb meaning get rid of from 1955 on. It was surely in reference to this meaning that Maxwell Smart, the hero of the 1960s sitcom Get Smart!, was Agent 86.
Galak

Reason: ''
Marcus
Da Tulip Champ I
Posts: 1664
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 1970 12:00 am
Location: Australian in London
Contact:

-off topic-

Post by Marcus »

I like a man who likes his etymology ;)

I could give you a barrowload of Australian slang you'd have a hell of a time getting through ;)

Nobody at work today knew what I was talking about when I mentioned that the receptionist was wearing a "Gosford Skirt"....

...ask Babs if you don't know what that one means.

Marcus

Reason: ''
Marcus
Da Tulip Champ I
Posts: 1664
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 1970 12:00 am
Location: Australian in London
Contact:

Post by Marcus »

I want to throw the ball to an empty square and catch it diving !!!
Toby: say you extend diving catch to allow players to catch a ball that was thrown accurately and intentionally to an adjacent square.

You could get a WE catcher or a gutter runner sprint and diving catch after only 2 skills and no doubles.

Say I have the aforementioned woodelf catcher and you're kicking to me. I start with my catcher on the line, retrieve the ball, then throw the ball to the square directly in front of the catcher (in your half) and take the diving catch.

My catcher now starts his turn 12 squares from your endzone and I have a 1 turn TD opportunity without having had a movement increase on my player.

That's why we decided not to allow diving catches on passes aimed at an empty square.

Marcus

Reason: ''
User avatar
Thadrin
Moaning Git
Posts: 8079
Joined: Mon Jul 30, 2001 12:00 am
Location: Norsca
Contact:

Post by Thadrin »

Throwing the ball deliberately to an empty square shouldn't be allowed anyway IMHO, with the exception of the Hail Mary Pass skill. Marcus' reasoning is just one more argument to add to the pile we already have.

Thanks for that Galak - fascinating stuff. Trying to find out if my team's name is just a coincidence now. Not too many of the original team left unfortunately. he he....gives all sorts of new meanings for our defence....

Reason: ''
I know a bear that you don't know. * ICEPELT IS MY HERO.
Master bleater. * Not in the clique.
Member of the "3 digit" club.
Toby

Post by Toby »

Marcus wrote: ...That's why we decided not to allow diving catches on passes aimed at an empty square.

You spoke about handicaps you tried to apply to make this more difficult.

I was thinking about "Catch" not allowed with "Diving Catch"...

Reason: ''
User avatar
Relborn
Super Star
Super Star
Posts: 1067
Joined: Fri Jul 05, 2002 8:09 am
Location: Stuttgart, Germany
Contact:

Diving Catch

Post by Relborn »

Or when using the OSPA rule ... which I really liked very much.
If you could only one skill per action I can't see any misuse from
it.

Does anybody knows why the OSPA is so widespread hated ? The rule sounded very reasonable to me...

Reason: ''
Toby

Post by Toby »

it kills skill combinations / that is one of the major features of BB

Reason: ''
Post Reply